Case Study

Why an MSP Switched from BullPhish ID to Phin security

Andrew Duey is the CEO at Wingman IT Services, a managed IT support, cloud management, and network security services provider. He oversaw Wingman IT's switch to Phin in March 2024 when the managed services provider was looking for security awareness training that was easy for clients to complete and easy for its team to manage. Following adoption, Phin has become a critical part of Wingman IT's fully managed services, and their average click rate on simulated phishing emails has fallen from 8% to 1%.

wave

Why Wingman IT Services Chose Phin Security for SAT

"Phin makes it simple to engage, to set it, to let it go, and doesn't require a lot of management... and the content was short and efficient for end-users." Andrew Duey, Wingman IT Services

 

Wingman IT evaluated Phin alongside five other providers, looking at how easily its team could set up each platform and how easily clients could use it. Phin stood out for its short and relevant training content and automated campaigns, which meant less hands-on work as the program grew.

Size

14 Clients

Active users

125+

CEO

Andrew Duey

Partner Since

March 2024

Previous Provider

BullPhish ID

Challenges

"The quality of training from BullPhish didn't hit the mark... the questions were almost insulting to me, and that's not what we wanted to put forth to our customers." - Andrew Duey, Wingman IT Services

 


  • Content felt immature, with frequent spelling and grammatical errors, unclear wording, and irrelevant assessment questions. Some quiz questions tested incidental details, such as the color of a bank building in a video, instead of the security lesson.

  • Wingman IT had to build each client’s campaigns manually, select the videos, and schedule them individually. They needed a set-it-and-forget-it solution that could run campaigns automatically.

Phin's Solution

"[Phin's] material was good and it seemed well thought out... and being able just to set it on autopilot, was what we were looking for." Andrew Duey, Wingman IT Services

 

Wingman IT has connected Phin to clients’ Microsoft Azure environments and created the groups it needs to launch training. Their recurring campaigns run automatically. Short videos make the material easier to fit into the workday, and Wingman IT uses a series of Phin videos to reinforce security basics during new-hire onboarding.

Phin also gives users a button to report suspicious emails. The button rewards users for reporting simulated phishing emails and sends suspected real phishing emails to Wingman IT for review. Wingman IT sets up automated reports for clients, especially those that need them for compliance. When users skip training, Wingman can share completion reports with client contacts so they can follow up.

Results

"Once we set it, it just runs and we don't have to do anything with it." Andrew Duey, Wingman IT Services

 

Phin’s security awareness training is now included in Wingman IT’s stack as one of its critical tools that every client needs.

87.5%
Decrease in average click rate. Wingman IT’s average click rate fell from 8% to 1% by August 2026.
15 min
Average time spent on initial setup per client. Now with Shared Campaigns, this can be done even faster.
~0 hrs
Average time spent managing Phin per month. Wingman IT spends most of its time in Phin onboarding new clients.
about-our-promise-top
five-stars

“Once we set it, it just runs and we don’t have to do anything with it... Probably one of our biggest flaws is we don't get in there on a regular basis and every once in a while get surprised by new features we didn't know were there.”

Andrew Duey

CEO, Wingman IT Services

White Testimonials_Channel Program & G2 Logo
wave

Features, Updates or Changes Wingman IT Services Wants to See

Duey identified no feature gaps and said the main remaining challenge was getting some users to complete assigned training, which he viewed as a matter for client HR teams.